The non-recognition of Islamic and Hindu marriages in South Africa

Islamic and Hindu marriages which are not accompanied by a civil ceremony, either in terms of the Marriage Act (Act 25 of 1961) or the Civil Union Act (Act 17 of 2006), are not recognised in South Africa and the parties are consequently considered as unmarried in the eyes of the law.

The reason for the non-recognition of Islamic and Hindu marriages is that generally Muslim and Hindu Priests have not been designated as marriages officers, although their designation is possible in terms of the Marriage Act. The further non-recognition of Islamic marriages is due to their potential polygamous nature which is seen as incompatible with the Marriage and Civil Union Acts.

Be that as it may, the non-recognition of these marriages in terms of South African law does have adverse consequences, more specifically for women.

Without a legal marriage, the parties are regarded as cohabitants. Simply put, this means that there are certain legal rights that are not available to either party that would ordinarily have been available if they had married in terms of the Marriage or Civil Union Act.

One of these rights is the right to claim maintenance. Cohabitees owe each other no duty of support, either during their relationship or at termination thereof. Therefore, a wife who is dependent on her husband, would not be entitled to enforce a right to claim maintenance in civil law should their religious marriage be dissolved.

A further consequence is that if one of the parties dies without a will (intestate), the surviving party will not have the right to inherit from the deceased estate as a spouse due to the non-recognition of their customary marriage.

Of course, religious rules regarding sharing of property and maintenance do still apply however, they will not be enforced by a civil court. This means that, unless the party conforms to religious pressure, the other party has no remedies.

In order to avoid this predicament, parties entering into Islamic and Hindu Marriages are encouraged to, after their religious ceremony, register their marriage at the Department of Home Affairs in terms of the Marriage Act or the Civil Union Act.

It should, however, be borne in mind that if the parties wish to register their marriage, the ordinary rules regarding in community of property and out of community of property will apply.

Should the parties wish to be married out of community of property an ante-nuptial contract must be executed before the registration of the marriage at the Department of Home Affairs. It can, therefore, be said that their religious ceremony has no bearing on their matrimonial property regime in terms of the law.

For more information please contact Robyn Pentz on 034 315 241 /